We’ve moved! Here’s where you can find us

The Green Ogre is now at https://www.greenogreindia.org
Showing posts with label gopi sundar. Show all posts
Showing posts with label gopi sundar. Show all posts

Encounter: The Bronzed Frog


In April 2006, we trekked from the Iruppu waterfalls in Kodagu (Coorg) to the Brahmagiri peak on the Karnataka-Kerala border. After crossing the lower bamboo-dominated patches we crossed a transition zone and reached a nice shola patch at the edge of the high-altitude grassland.


That's where we saw the frog. We found this individual near a small clear-water stream where we had stopped for lunch. In the dappled sunlight of the shola floor, a few individuals were perched on rocks close to the water. It was wet and quite well camouflaged among the rust, brown and maroon leaves sticking to wet stream rocks. The Bronzed Frog was not shy and stayed with us while we lunched, graciously allowing us to photograph it and allowing a close approach.

The common name of the frog is derived from the striking bronze strips that begin from near the snout, continue down the lower jaw, and run along the sides of the body to the lower limbs. The back is brown with bronze spotting and the hind limbs have broken bronze stripes. These strips appear just after the metamorphosis is complete. The Bronzed Frog is an important prey species for the Malabar Pit Viper (Trimeresurus malabaricus), another endemic species that loves the same moist, wet and green canopy-covered shola habitat. Hylarana temporalis was first described in 1864 and is endemic to the Indian subcontinent. It is found in the evergreen forests of the Western Ghats and the Sri Lankan highlands.
Hylarana temporalis or Bronzed Frog is similar to Hylarana aurantiaca, another endemic. H. temporalis is also found in slightly disturbed areas, but H. aurantiaca prefers only fairly pristine canopy-covered streams.
While an alarming die-out of amphibians, especially frogs, has been recorded in recent years, new species continue to be discovered across the world, including the Western Ghats. In early 2009, amphibian researchers S.D. Biju of Delhi University's Systematics Lab and Franky Bossuyt of the Amphibian Evolution Lab of the Vrije Universiteit Brussel announced the discovery of 12 new species of tree frogs from the Western Ghats. Dr Biju also rediscovered the Travancore Bushfrog (Philautus travancoricus), which had not been sighted in 100 years and was hence believed to be extinct. Approximately 126 amphibian species have been described from the Western Ghats.

Another species, Raorchestes resplendens, was recently described from the Eravikulam National Park and is believed to be restricted to a 3 sq km range on the summit of Anaimudi (the highest peak in the Western Ghats), further reinforcing the status of the Western Ghats as an important bio-diversity hotspot.
Text and photographs by Sahastrarashmi
Thanks to K S Gopi Sundar for ID help.

Invasive Species: When green journalism turns yellow

By crying wolf over green issues, ill-informed journalists are indulging in yellow journalism. The recent scare-mongering by the national media over the "death" of the wetland bird sanctuary of Sultanpur is a case in point. 

Keoladeo Ghana park director Anoop KR holding an invasive Mangur catfish and the partially consumed leg of a bird retrieved from its digestive tract


Over the last two weeks the national media -- particularly Delhi-based newspapers and television channels -- have been beating their breasts and wailing about the imminent death of wetland ecosystems such as Bharatpur and Sultanpur (the former in Rajasthan, the latter in Haryana). Both these bird sanctuaries are canal-fed wetland ecosystems whose health and survival depend on riverine water inflow: Bharatpur is fed by a canal from the Bhima river, while Sultanpur depends on water channeled from the Gurgaon canal that diverts water from the Yamuna.


On June 16, The Hindustan Times reported that Sultanpur lake had dried up and that the future of the wetland sanctuary was imperiled. Excerpt:
As a grim reminder of the future, the bodies of two African Black fish, with their rotten yellow scales and broken bones, lie beside each other on the parched, cracked earth. Barely six feet away, the grey carrion of a Blue Bull (Neelgai), with its torso missing but tiny horn and moldy skin intact, engages the attention of a solitary crow.
At first read, this comes across as serious reportage of an environmental disaster. In truth, it is just theatre of the verbose. HT quoted Minister for Environment and Forests Jairam Ramesh, well known for his love of expressing opinion that he has not had time to adequately consider, as writing in an open letter to Haryana Chief Minister Bhupinder Singh Hooda: “You are well aware of the history of the park and the role that Indira Gandhi played in having it declared as a sanctuary way back in 1972. It is doubly unfortunate that a sanctuary with Gandhi’s name is so closely associated should find itself in such a pathetic state.” 


Spoken like a true Congress loyalist. Except that since the sanctuary was notified, nobody in the great party has spared a thought for it. Except perhaps another Gandhi that the Congress doesn't quite favour. Maneka Gandhi, the outlawed daughter-in-law of the first family, was briefly associated in the media with Sultanpur but not in a way that any birder or environmentalist would appreciate. With her blinkered animal rights philosophy she resisted, for long, every measure by concerned environmentalists to evict feral dogs, which posed great threat to nesting birds and nestlings (see my video about dogs in Sultanpur). Eventually, the dogs were evicted but only after a lot of damage was already done.


The me-too media kowtowed, with journalists barely stopping to hold their breaths to investigate the facts. The television channel CNN-IBN, well-known for its shrieky alarmist stand on issues (modeled on the personality of its chief), pronounced that all was not well with Sultanpur. The ticker screamed: "Dead fish raise a stink".


The Times of India, not always saluted for its objectivity, surprised us pleasantly by showing reason in the face of blind speculation. Its story, carried on the same day as the HT story, pointed us to the source of the problem. The paper quoted Keshni Anand Arora, commissioner and principal secretary of forests in Haryana, as blaming the introduced African catfish or Mangur for predating on indigenous fish species and birds. 


Therein lay the tale. The African Mangur or Sharptooth Catfish (Clarias gariepinus), sometimes known as the Walking Catfish, occurs naturally from South Africa to northern Africa all the way up to southern Europe. It is a hardy and adaptive fish with extremely well-developed lungs that allow it to survive outside an aqueous environment for prolonged periods, including extended spells of drought (as witnessed this past summer in northern India). In fact, when pressed, the mangur actually walks on land using its fins to move from one water body to another. 


The Mangur was illegally introduced into India from Bangladesh and its cultivation is banned in some parts of the country. In May 2009, The Hindu reported: The breeding of African catfish is banned in India in the wake of an order by the Kerala High Court back in 2000. The case, on the basis of a petition from Kerala’s fish breeders, was referred by the Court to the National Committee on Exotic Species, which in turn recommended its ban. The African mangur, which grows into huge sizes, is not preferred even by traditional fish-eating communities who consider it “not very tasty”.


It was Mint, however, that brought out the best-reported and comprehensive coverage of the issue on Monday, highlighting the need for controlling the propagation of invasive species citing the case of the Magur as a flashpoint. The Mint story, by Padmaparna Ghosh, included a slideshow about invasive species and a video interview with my friend Gopi Sundar, research associate of the International Crane Foundation and an expert on wetland ecology. The story also quoted Anoop KR, director of the Keoladeo Ghana National Park in Bharatpur, who has been working at exterminating the invasive fish in his park. The bloated bellies of the mangur, which can grow up to 30 ft long, aroused suspicions which his dissections subsequently confirmed. The mangur in Bharatpur had been eating birds in additional to indigenous fish species.


It's pretty much the same story in Sultanpur, albeit under-reported. This summer, water has not been plentiful and the swamps have dried. The sanctuary has been sealed off and that explains why the nilgai -- considered a crop pest in these parts -- are dying off. The authorities are concertedly ridding the wetland of mangur and hoping that the extirpation of the species from the sanctuary will allow more native species of fish to breed and encourage birds to come back to the lake.


The shock of drought, Gopi explains, is actually beneficial to certain kinds of wetlands. The real issue -- that of invasive species -- must be addressed across the country. Lantana, a weed introduced accidentally from South America as an ornamental, now chokes the undergrowth in forests across the country. Its impact can be seen in the mixed deciduous forests of the Western Ghats. Parthenium, introduced along with wheat imports from America, is also widespread in Indian forests. Some native species have adapted well to the introduced varieties. Lantana, for instance, is favoured by some species of butterflies as well as bulbuls, sunbirds and flowerpeckers. Various NGOs including Atree and NCF are at work on projects to control the spread of invasive species. For concerned mediapersons, that should provide the context for the story.


A cabbage white butterfly on a lantana blossom. Lantana camara, native to South America, was introduced by gardeners. Pollination by local butterflies and berries spread by bulbuls, flowerpeckers and other local species make its control very difficult. 


I was disappointed by the reaction of some "concerned birders" and "activists" (who otherwise run profitable birding tours for Indians and expats) to the situation at hand. By fomenting the interest of ill-informed journalists in non-crises such as the annual cycle of flooding and drought in the wetlands of the subcontinent, these "friends of the environment" are stabbing it in the back. These are trying times, when every media vehicle worth its TRP (or self-funded readership survey) wants to appropriate the issue of "green journalism". It pays to be patient, talk to the real experts, and refrain from alarmist coverage altogether. 


Message to journos: hankering for scoops belongs in the realm of journalism of a different colour -- yellow, not green.


PHOTOS: (C) GOPI SUNDAR AND SWATI KITTUR

The Sarus blogger is finally online

IMAGE: SARUS AND NILGAI (FROM K S GOPI SUNDAR'S SARUS SCAPES) My dear friend Gopi Sundar has finally lifted the veil on his stupendous insight into bird behaviour. His blog 'Sarus Scape' is now online and abuzz. He tags his blog 'Random Observations of a Wandering Naturalist' but that entire line is a euphemism for what he does best. His observations are far from random - they are marked by extraordinary scientific precision. And though he may like to imagine himself as a peripatetic hobo, his journeys are anything but wanderings - well, if you and I marked an entire state into little squares and transected each one to document its birdlife, we wouldn't call that wandering. But my friend has a yen for understatement. Enough said. Please enjoy Sarus Scape.

Agriculture and bird diversity - some findings

The winter of 08-09 has now packed away its woollies and headed off into the southern hemisphere to cool things off. But while we argued about the patterns of bird migration, the late arrival of migrants (some entirely absent) and blamed global warming for our frustrations, a biologist I know has braved the odds and conducted one of the most comprehensive bird surveys conducted in Uttar Pradesh in recent times. Streams in the agricultural landscape make excellent foraging grounds for a variety of waterbirds. The man (not in picture) is Gopi Sundar, whom readers of this blog have met virtually many times over. Gopi, as the International Crane Foundation's research associate and principal coordinator of the Indian Cranes and Wetlands Working Group, is well known for his study of Sarus cranes and their habitat in the rice-dominated agricultural landscape of Uttar Pradesh. Gopi spent the winter braving dense fog and the political mafia to execute a painstaking survey of the bird diversity in this ecosystem. He used a grid-based sampling design with space-for-time replication to test for variations in "observed patterns of bird species richness and abundance due to four different intensities of rice cultivation". His study documented 198 bird species in 160 transects. Yellow Wagtails are a relatively common species in Uttar Pradesh's cultivated areas. They are one of the last migrants to leave and can be seen feeding on insects in ripening wheat fields in early summer. Gopi's report begins with this arresting declaration: "Agriculture is the biggest threat to bird diversity worldwide." The Hindu published a report based on his work in its national edition. It opens with the very same statement. Gopi's findings suggests that agriculturists hark back to traditional land-use methods, which preserved natural habitats and enabled bird diversity. Preserving islands of natural habitat and avoiding mono-cropping or monocultures can be important steps in this direction. The Hindu report can be read here. PHOTOGRAPHS: © K. S. GOPI SUNDAR/ ICF. USED WITH PERMISSION. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED.